Skip to Main Content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Systematic Reviews for Health: 1. Formulate the Research Question

A guide on how a Research Librarian can help you during a systematic review process

Step 1. Formulate the Research Question

A systematic review is based on a pre-defined specific research question (Cochrane Handbook, 1.1). The first step in a systematic review is to determine its focus - you should clearly frame the question(s) the review seeks to answer (Cochrane Handbook, 2.1). It may take you a while to develop a good review question - it is an important step in your review. Well-formulated questions will guide many aspects of the review process, including determining eligibility criteria, searching for studies, collecting data from included studies, and presenting findings (Cochrane Handbook, 2.1).

The research question should be clear and focused - not too vague, too specific or too broad.

You may like to consider some of the techniques mentioned below to help you with this process. They can be useful but are not necessary for a good search strategy.

Techniques

PICO - to search for quantitative review questions

P I C O
Patient, Population Intervention (or Exposure) Comparison (or Control)
if appropriate
Outcome
Most important characteristics of patient (e.g. age, disease/condition, gender) Main intervention (e.g. drug treatment, diagnostic/screening test) Main alternative (e.g. placebo, standard therapy, no treatment, gold standard) What you are trying to accomplish, measure, improve, affect (e.g. reduced mortality or morbidity, improved memory)

Richardson, WS, Wilson, MC, Nishikawa, J & Hayward, RS 1995, 'The well-built clinical question: A key to evidence-based decisions', ACP Journal Club, vol. 123, no. 3, pp. A12-A12.

We do not have access to this article at UTAS.

A variant of PICO is PICOS. S stands for Study designs. It establishes which study designs are appropriate for answering the question, e.g. randomised controlled trial (RCT). There is also PICOC (C for context) and PICOT (T for timeframe).


 

SPIDER - to search for qualitative and mixed methods research studies

S PI D E R
Sample Phenomenon of Interest Design Evaluation Research type

Cooke, A, Smith, D & Booth, A 2012, 'Beyond pico the spider tool for qualitative evidence synthesis', Qualitative Health Research, vol. 22, no. 10, pp. 1435-1443.

This article is only accessible for UTAS staff and students.


SPICE - to search for qualitative evidence

S P I C E
Setting (where?) Perspecitve (for whom?) Intervention (what?) Comparison (compared with what?) Evaluation (with what result?)

Cleyle, S & Booth, A 2006, 'Clear and present questions: Formulating questions for evidence based practice', Library hi tech, vol. 24, no. 3, pp. 355-368.

We do not have access to this article at UTAS.


ECLIPSE - to search for health policy/management information

E C L I P Se
Expectation (improvement or information or innovation) Client group (at whom the service is aimed) Location (where is the service located?) Impact (outcomes) Professionals (who is involved in providing/improving the service) Service (for which service are you looking for information)

Wildridge, V & Bell, L 2002, 'How clip became eclipse: A mnemonic to assist in searching for health policy/management information', Health Information & Libraries Journal, vol. 19, no. 2, pp. 113-115.

This article is only accessible for UTAS staff and students.

Example

This is the specific research question used in the example:

"Is animal-assisted therapy more effective than music therapy in managing aggressive behaviour in elderly people with dementia?"

 

Within this question are the four PICO concepts:

P elderly patients with dementia
I animal-assisted therapy
C music therapy
O aggressive behaviour

S - Study design

This is a therapy question. The best study design to answer a therapy question is a randomised controlled trial (RCT). You may decide to only include studies in the systematic review that were using a RCT, see Step 8.


See source of example

Need More Help?
Book a consultation with a Learning and Research Librarian or contact Librarians@utas.edu.au.